As China’s growth headwinds gather speed, Beijing must consider cash handouts to sustain ‘common prosperity’ drive
- While the government has put on a brave face as economic storm clouds gather, retail and household income figures suggest the nation’s leaders are being too optimistic
- Authorities have thus far focused on boosting production, but sustaining the much-touted ‘common prosperity’ drive might require direct subsidies to those most in need
China may have reported stronger-than-expected economic expansion in the first quarter of 2022, but pessimism about the outlook for the coming quarters, and even the whole year, is worsening – for good reason.
In the first three months, the world’s second-largest economy grew by 4.8 per cent compared to the same period last year.
That growth rate may be slower than the government’s set target, but it is higher than the 4 per cent rate it grew in the last quarter of 2021 as well as the estimates of economists.
Consequently, tens of millions of residents were quarantined at home, factories and businesses closed and supply chains severely disrupted.
Foreign vaccines, self-test kits could help China optimise its Covid policy
Beijing has thus far put on a brave face. Since Monday, authorities have directed state media to publish a barrage of commentaries and analysis pieces that argue that China’s economic fundamentals remain strong, with its resilience and vitality intact.
The Chinese leadership have been singing this tune since late last year, even as they warned that the economy would soon face more headwinds because of three major risks – contracting demand, supply chain disruptions and weakening expectations.
Since then, leaders including Premier Li Keqiang have further cautioned that downward economic pressures would worsen as rising complexities and uncertainties at home and abroad take their toll.
Thus far, the government’s response has been cautious, to say the least.
03:27
My take: living under Shanghai’s Covid-19 lockdown
The 25 basis-point move was smaller than expected and has failed to impress the markets. The International Monetary Fund, meanwhile, cut its growth forecast for China this year to 4.4 per cent – the second such reduction in three months.
The world financial body’s forecast is now much lower than Beijing’s own target of 5.5 per cent and major international banks have also mostly downgraded their estimates for China to below 5 per cent.
That is because its leaders are always mindful of the painful lessons learned from the great easing following the 2008 global financial crisis, and they also expect the economy to bounce back in the latter half of the year once the latest Covid-19 outbreak is tamed – repeating the feat achieved in 2020 and 2021.
China’s zero-Covid policy causes widespread hardships. So why keep it?
But this may be too optimistic, some insiders believe. Wang Yongli, former deputy governor of Bank of China, recently wrote that the Chinese government must prepare for bigger shocks, perhaps even greater than the impact felt from 2008’s economic pain.
He urged Beijing to prepare a massive economic stimulus package that includes a plan to prop up capital markets and ramp up social assistance programmes.
Wang’s warning is worth heeding. China should overcome its reservations and be ready to undertake comprehensive monetary, fiscal, property, and regulatory easing.
To be sure, over the past few months various central government departments, including the National Development and Reform Commission and the PBOC have made a raft of policy pledges to help businesses battered by Covid-19 outbreaks and lockdowns.
But those steps are limited as they mainly focus on boosting production instead of lifting consumer spending.
In March, retail sales fell 3.5 per cent, the first such contraction in nearly two years, compared to growth of 6.7 per cent in the first two months.
Household disposable income, meanwhile, only saw growth of 6.3 per cent in the first quarter. That figure was lower than the pre-pandemic level of 8.7 per cent for the first quarter of 2019. The latest quarterly survey on consumer spending by the PBOC reflected this weakening trend.
These numbers are among the more compelling reasons for Beijing to focus on boosting consumer spending. China should also learn from the US and Europe and offer bigger direct cash payments or cash vouchers.
Beijing stopped the panic in stock markets, but it must do more
In 2020, a number of mostly wealthy cities handed out cash vouchers but the impact was limited because the people in the less prosperous urban and rural areas failed to benefit.
This year’s outbreak has again hit low-income families the hardest, with prolonged lockdowns in many cities causing them to be quarantined at home and makeshift hospitals without pay or social assistance.
But the government has long been averse to placing money in the hands of the people and instead prefers to focus state-led investment on infrastructure projects.
It is time to change this mindset. If the current situation continues, it could risk widening the country’s income gap – going against the economic-equality drive China’s leaders have been so keen to promote under the high-sounding slogan of “common prosperity”.
Wang Xiangwei is a former editor-in-chief of the South China Morning Post. He is now based in Beijing as editorial adviser to the paper
