Chief executive election: three areas where candidates can transform Hong Kong governance
- Carrie Lam’s proposal for reorganising the government structure provides an opportunity for potential candidates to express new perspectives
- Key challenges include how to tackle climate change, digitalisation and economic progress, to better serve the public
Aspiring candidates will have to state their visions and policies for Hong Kong. A persuasive manifesto must resonate with the people and fit the trajectory of national development. Hong Kong’s leader should also have an appealing international message.
A popular incumbent has it relatively easy. But tremendous effort is required for someone whose popularity has waned to show that the incumbent is still the best person to guide society under ever more complex circumstances. A challenger needs to have new ideas and must appear to be the better choice.
Despite the fact the general public cannot vote directly for their leader, ordinary folk are still interested in what kind of person will be in charge for the coming five years. Hence, there will be great interest even if there won’t be the fanfare associated with a popular election.
Of course, there are many ways for candidates to shape their manifestos. Policy articulation in Hong Kong often takes the form of a list: a long menu of initiatives wrapped in bureaucratic language.
One way to depart from this could be with a “future forward” narrative, demonstrating a good grasp of the transformation needed by Hong Kong.
Birthday party fiasco an insult to a community that deserves better
The proposed restructuring is intended to enhance the effectiveness of governance and meet society’s expectations. Understandably, it takes current policy focuses as the starting point.
This “list approach” could be reorganised to show how the government can use its full capabilities to meet complex challenges, three of which are locally, nationally and globally relevant.
International and national financial regulations are evolving to include climate and sustainability risk assessments for companies that will affect their ability to raise capital.
The second challenge is digitalisation, which needs to be pushed through effective policymaking.
Digital competence needs to be woven into every aspect of the administration, business and society to improve governance, city planning and infrastructure, the environment, industry, competitiveness, productivity, education, social communication and more.
Greener buildings can help Hong Kong become carbon neutral by 2050
Taken together, there is an opportunity for political leaders in Hong Kong to reframe how they can best serve the public. As part of the restructuring, the three challenges can be used to help guide the distribution of responsibilities.
The three topics also overlap so the chief secretary and financial secretary should demand aggressive approaches coordinated across bureaus and departments to ensure Hong Kong is in a leading position to tackle them head-on.
This will be possible with a clear command at the top and policy integration, involving principal officials and the civil service, pursued vigorously. Rightly, the proposal includes the reinstatement of a separate post of director of environmental protection, separating it from the current combined role with the permanent secretary for the environment, but that will not be enough.
Buildings, including housing, must be green and designed to help lower temperatures in the city, which will reduce health risks to the ageing population. Infectious diseases, public health, environment and sanitation are closely related, and the restructuring needs to clarify how risks are addressed holistically.
Reindustralisation requires green and digital advances, which must dovetail with national carbon-neutral and circular-economy policies. Logistics is about decarbonisation and digitalisation too, which affects trucking, shipping and aviation.
The restructuring discussion in the newly elected legislature represents the opening of the chief executive election season.
Christine Loh, a former undersecretary for the environment, is an adjunct professor at Hong Kong University of Science and Technology