Advertisement
Advertisement
Singapore
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong. Photo: Reuters

Singapore’s PAP, opposition trade barbs over ‘less than upfront’ handling of political scandals

  • Opposition chief Pritam Singh claims the government was slow to release information on events that put the ruling party in a bad light
  • PAP lawmakers hit back, with PM Lee saying Singh’s remarks are akin to ‘pursuing a red herring’
Singapore
Singapore’s ruling party and opposition lawmakers on Wednesday traded recriminations over the country’s recent series of political scandals, as both sides sought to deflect accusations they had each been opaque in dealing with the sagas.
The stormy back-and-forth in parliament followed a statement by Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong on the recent arrest – and suspension from duties – of Transport Minister S. Iswaran following a corruption investigation and the resignation of two MPs from the ruling People’s Action Party (PAP) for having an extramarital affair.

The unusual clutch of misdeeds at the highest levels of the country’s usually staid politics also involves the main opposition Workers’ Party (WP).

One of its nine MPs, Leon Perera, resigned last month – also after his extramarital affair with a party colleague came to light.
Former parliamentary speaker Tan Chuan-Jin and MP Cheng Li Hui. Photo: Lianhe Zaobao via Reuters
Prime Minister Lee in his speech admitted that his long-ruling party had “taken a hit” following the sagas involving its members, but pledged to ensure accountability even if it proved politically painful or embarrassing.

“Systems are composed of human beings,” Lee said. “In any system, however comprehensive the safeguards, sometimes something will still go wrong.”

Lee, 71, also admitted that he ought to have intervened earlier in dealing with the affair involving former parliamentary speaker Tan Chuan-Jin and MP Cheng Li Hui. He has faced criticism for not forcing their resignations earlier, despite gaining knowledge of their affair in 2020.

In response to Lee’s speech, the WP’s chief Pritam Singh assailed the government for what he claimed was a pattern of being slow to release information on events that put the ruling party in a bad light.

“In this term of government, the government has either been slow to clear the air or been less than upfront and forthright with Singaporeans when it had to deal with potentially embarrassing issues,” he said.

Workers’ Party chief Pritam Singh. Photo: Reuters

Singh, the leader of the opposition, raised the example of the government’s response to the MPs’ affair and Iswaran’s July 11 arrest, as well as two other recent episodes.

This included a recent month-long corruption investigation into veteran ministers who had rented state-owned bungalows, and a separate episode of public disquiet in 2020 and 2021, when authorities belatedly revealed to the public that law enforcement agencies could use the republic’s Covid-19 contact-tracing app TraceTogether for criminal investigations.
In the corruption probe, Prime Minister Lee did not immediately reveal in May that he had directed the anti-corruption agency to investigate ministers K. Shanmugam and Vivian Balakrishnan, though he made public a separate probe he had ordered into the matter by his most trusted minister, Teo Chee Hean.

Both probes found the ministers committed no wrongdoing, but the formal anti-corruption probe was only revealed when the findings of both investigations were made public on June 28.

02:01

Singapore’s political scandal deepens as 2 MPs resign amid separate high-profile corruption probe

Singapore’s political scandal deepens as 2 MPs resign amid separate high-profile corruption probe

“Unlike as represented by the PM, these are not events that I quote ‘are clustered together, all coming in one go’,” Singh said in his remarks. The opposition chief accused the PAP of “engaging in half-truths on matters of significant public interest”.

This behaviour, Singh said, was the main reason behind “disquiet among Singaporeans” over the ruling party’s constant comments about trust in government and its invocation of its founding generation of leaders.

He cited these examples as justification for the need for an appointment of an ethics adviser, urging Lee to “reconsider his position in view of the PAP’s pattern of behaviour in this term of government, especially when a potentially embarrassing issue comes up”.

Nicole Seah and Leon Perera of Singapore’s Workers’ Party. Photo: Handout

Singh’s hard-hitting remarks drew equally forceful responses from the PAP front bench.

Prime Minister Lee described the opposition leader’s remarks on the delay in the transmission of information as “pursuing a red herring”, saying there were questions to be asked about how the WP handled Perera’s affair with party colleague Nicole Seah.

Singh and other party leaders have faced some criticism on social media over their handling of the saga. They had questioned Perera and Seah after hearing allegations of their affair from Perera’s driver, but the matter was dropped following denials.

Later on in the debate, the prime minister – responding to Leong Mun Wai of the minor opposition Progress Singapore Party – suggested the matter was being debated in parliament in the first place precisely because of the PAP’s responsiveness to wrongdoing within its ranks.

“The reason this is here at all is because this government decided to act. ‘Ownself check ownself’,” Lee said, using a Singlish phrase first coined by Singh to deride the ruling PAP’s claim that it did not require an opposition to keep it in check.

“Otherwise, it wouldn’t even be here,” he added, referencing Leong’s remarks on Iswaran.

Singaporeans weigh morality in politics as adultery, corruption sagas ‘blow up’

Balakrishnan, who was in Singh’s cross hairs over the TraceTogether affair – he was the minister in charge of the platform – strongly denied the opposition chief’s “insinuation” that there had been undue delay or attempted obfuscation on his part.

Despite questions for more details on the probe involving Iswaran – the country’s highest-profile graft investigation in four decades – Lee and Chan Chun Sing, the minister in charge of the public service, offered few new details as the investigation was ongoing.

There has been some speculation that the probe may have to do with the republic’s hosting of the Formula One night race.

Alongside Iswaran, property billionaire Ong Beng Seng was also arrested and subsequently released on bail. Iswaran and Ong, 77, would have interacted over the years as a matter of course, with the minister’s roles in trade and transport intersecting with the tycoon known for helping bring the F1 Grand Prix to Singapore.

Additional reporting by Bloomberg

8