Advertisement
Advertisement
Portuguese forward Cristiano Ronaldo celebrates after scoring for Juventus in the Italian Serie A match against Hellas Verona. Photo: AFP
Opinion
On The Ball
by Andy Mitten
On The Ball
by Andy Mitten

Cristiano Ronaldo’s ‘coronavirus hotels’ another of football’s fake feel-good stories

  • Portugal star was widely reported to be turning his hotels into coronavirus hospitals but it was not true
  • Fake quotes on past players are harmless but rumours risk turning on subject when exposed

The “news” went viral on Sunday, a feel-good story for these feel bad times. Cristiano Ronaldo would turn his chain of hotels in Portugal into hospitals for people affected by Covid-19. Not only that, he would pay the salaries of all the doctors and nurses.

Hundreds of websites repeated this story including established news outlets like Marca’s website (but not the actual paper) in Spain and TalkSport’s website in England. Last Thursday, Marca’s website also wrote that all the Europa League gamed would be cancelled with immediate effect … which was news to the clubs about to play games behind closed doors. And they did play those games.

For the Ronaldo story, the clicks and likes ticked over into their tens of thousands, with so many comments agreeing what a great guy Ronaldo was. They wrote “classy gesture” complete with an emoji of a handclap. There was even credit from people who positively identify as Lionel Messi fans above supporters of any football club. If you want to find a weird subsection of the web, then it’s Messi and Ronaldo fans arguing with each other over who is the best and objecting to any journalist who plumps for the other.

The story came from a TV journalist Adriano Del Monte, who has a verified blue Twitter tick. His tweet was: “Cristiano Ronaldo’s @PestanaCR7 hotels will become hospitals next week, where patients in Portugal will be treated free of charge. He will pay all medical staff. #COVID19 What a man.”

Barcelona's Lionel Messi celebrates scoring in 2018. He did not grow up idolising Paul Scholes. Photo: Reuters

There was only one problem: the story was a hoax.

A spokesman for the hotel denied it. Ronaldo made no mention of it because it’s not true. Hotels are having a hard time of it as it is without having to be linked to being turned into hospitals to treat those suffering with the virus. AFP were told by the chain: “The information is inaccurate. We did not receive any indication in this regard.”

Ronaldo and Messi are regularly the subject of hoax stories. My editor at FourFourTwo magazine asked me to check out a story about Albert Fantrau, supposedly a childhood friend of Ronaldo who had a trial with him at Sporting Lisbon. Having beaten several players and with only an open goal to put the ball into, Fantrau selflessly passed to Cristiano “because you are better than me” – Ronaldo was then the recipient of a contract rather than Fantrau. I called contacts in Lisbon and they confirmed that it was a hoax.

As a journalism student, one of my peers told a lecturer that he had a great story. He’d heard of a story about a man who got drunk and woke up in a street with one of his kidneys missing. There was, he said, a black market in stolen kidneys. Other students were shocked, since they too were potential targets.

Manchester United's Paul Scholes celebrates his goal against Bolton Wanderers in 2012. Photo: Reuters

“Fantastic story,” said the lecturer. “Now get to the people involved and speak to them. If you can’t get to the person who had his kidney stolen, the person selling the kidneys or the doctors doing illegal, get some witnesses.”

The student nodded, but he could never find any of the above because it was a complete fabrication.

Football, like everywhere else in these online days, is full of fake news and it is very difficult to discern what is true or not, partly because it is often plausible. The big lies are relatively easy to spot, not so the smaller ones which flood out every day. People want their prejudices reinforced, they want to read of generous gestures by people they admire.

Barcelona's Andres Iniesta and Messi hold the Champions League trophy after beating Manchester United in 2009. Photo: AP

There are regularly false quotes about the former Manchester United player Paul Scholes from other great players. If they’re accompanied by a photo of the player then somehow adds credibility for some. I know they’re fake because I spoke to four of the people quoted to ask them specifically about Scholes. The Brazilian legend Socrates complimented him unprompted when I met him in Sao Paulo in March 10, 2010 – it was supposed to be a day earlier but he went to carnival with Zico and turned up a day late.

I asked Andres Iniesta, Lionel Messi and Xavi about Scholes – for his testimonial programme, complete with an invite to play in his testimonial game. Those interviews were done in August 2011 at the training ground on the day that Alexis Sanchez joined Barcelona.

They all agreed that Scholes was a great player, but the quotes I see now are nothing like what was actually said. They’ve been twisted and contorted. Messi simply did not sit watching video tapes of Scholes at La Masia in the hope that one day he could emulate him as the web would have you believe.

Not that this example is particularly dangerous, even though when established sources repeat these fake quotes but what about the Ronaldo story? I struck by the number of people I’d consider intelligent retweeting or commenting on it. They really wanted to believe that it was true. And then there’s a backlash – because, the online logic goes, shouldn’t someone as wealthy as Ronaldo be doing this anyway? Suddenly, by implication, he’s mean and selfish.

Post