Hong Kong must stop clinging to the fiction of racial superiority and treat foreign domestic helpers with respect
Anson Au says Hong Kong people’s racial prejudice against Filipino and Indonesian helpers must give way in the face of evidence that race is essentially a social construct
Marrying a white-skinned partner is traditionally seen as a necessary improvement to one’s social standing and status. West is best.
The core beliefs behind both perspectives are the same: that social differences are inherent to race and that race is immutable, obvious and stamped onto the shade of one’s skin. Behind the colour of our skin lie many assumptions: heritage, attitudes, dispositions, languages, identities. This ideology hides an uncomfortable and not-so-obvious truth: that race itself is a social construct.
Not all white: how K-pop and Asian hip hop made tanned look popular with some subcultures
Just last month, researchers at the London Natural History Museum recreated the appearance of Cheddar Man, famously Britain’s oldest complete skeleton dating back over 10,000 years. He was what we would today call black, shattering commonly held beliefs that British people have always been, are, and will be white. Tom Booth, an archaeologist who worked on the project, said: “It really shows up that these imaginary racial categories that we have are really very modern constructions, or very recent constructions, that really are not applicable to the past at all.”
Likewise, the inadequacies we point out in Hong Kong’s foreign-born domestic workers are not inherently linked to race, but reflections of the social conditions they live in.
Black, white or yellow, we’re all Hong Kong, say players as they shrug off Chinese FA ad
Recognising that Filipinos deserve our empathy as migrant workers in a host society that pays them disproportionately less than their local counterparts is a promising start. As is stripping the false shine off Westerners, framed as paragons.
Reshaping the ways we think about the few is essential to the way we develop policies for the many. Doing so is the only way to move towards a more equitable society, where meritocracy trumps bias, where empathy beats prejudice, and where life flourishes without judgment.
Anson Au is a visiting researcher in the Department of Sociology at Hong Kong Baptist University